On this page
01 How the scheme works
Multi-level marketing (MLM), also called network marketing or direct selling, is a way of selling products through independent “distributors” instead of shops. You don’t get a salary. You earn in two ways: a margin or commission on what you sell yourself, and a bonus on what the people you signed up — your “downline” — buy and sell. Those people sign up others, and you earn a small share of that too. That’s the “multi-level” part.
On paper, that sounds like a normal sales job with a bonus for building a team. In practice, the question is always the same: where does the money really come from? If it comes mainly from real customers who want the product, it can be a legal business model. If it comes mainly from new recruits paying to join and buying products to stay “active”, the money simply flows upwards — from the many at the bottom to the few at the top.
- You get recruited
- You buy a starter kit
- Monthly orders to stay “active”
- You recruit others
- Bonuses flow upwards
- Most end in the red
The four money machines inside many MLMs
02 Why it looks tempting
Let’s be clear: nobody joins an MLM because they are stupid. People join because the offer hits real needs — often at a hard moment. You lost your job, your hours were cut, you’re at home with small children, or you’re afraid AI will replace you. Then a friendly message arrives.
- “Be your own boss.” Freedom from a bad manager and fixed hours is a strong wish, especially after a layoff.
- “Work from your phone.” It sounds flexible and easy to fit around family life.
- Community. Group chats, calls, hearts and cheers. For lonely people this feels like a new family — and it makes leaving much harder later.
- Low entry, high dream. A starter kit costs less than a course or a shop. The talk is about cars, trips and “financial freedom”.
- A friend asks you. Most recruiting happens through people you know. You trust them — and they usually believe in it themselves.
- The product might be okay. Skincare, supplements, cleaning products, essential oils, coffee, even “trading education”. The product is often not the problem. The pay plan is.
Social media made all of this louder. Your feed shows the car reveal, the beach laptop, the “I just hit a new rank!” post. You don’t see the people who quietly stopped, the stock under the bed, or the credit card bill. That’s not an accident: posting success is part of the recruiting training.
03 What the numbers really say
And you don’t have to trust our opinion. Look at what regulators found when they checked the companies’ own figures.
In September 2024, staff of the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) published a report on income disclosure statements — the documents where MLMs show what their distributors earn. The findings: many participants received no payment at all, the vast majority received $1,000 or less per year, and in at least 17 of the 70 companies, most participants made nothing. Those are gross payments from the company — the starter kit, the monthly orders, the events, the fuel and the phone bill are not subtracted.
The FTC also found that many of these statements are presented in a confusing way. They highlight the small group at the top, show “averages” that mix very different incomes, and hide or leave out the people who earned nothing. In its official business guidance, the FTC says it plainly: “Most MLM participants earn little to no money.” Its consumer advice adds that some people lose money.
How to read an income disclosure statement
In January 2025 the FTC also proposed new rules to fight deceptive earnings claims — one aimed specifically at MLMs, and changes to its Business Opportunity Rule for other money-making offers. Whether and in what form these rules become final is open. But the direction is clear: regulators know that income promises are the main hook.
Sources: FTC staff report on MLM income disclosure statements (Sept 2024); FTC Business Guidance Concerning Multi-Level Marketing; FTC press release on proposed earnings claim rules (Jan 2025). Figures are in US dollars as published.
04 Warning signs
Every one of these on it’s own is a reason to slow down. Three or more together: walk away.
- Avoid: The pitch is more about recruiting people than about selling to customers.
- Avoid: You must pay to join — a starter kit, a “business pack”, a sign-up fee.
- Avoid: You need a monthly minimum order to stay “active” or keep your bonus.
- Avoid: Leaders say “just buy for yourself first”, or “fake it till you make it”.
- Avoid: Big income talk — cars, trips, “replace your salary” — but no clear numbers after costs.
- Avoid: Pressure: “only 3 spots left”, “decide tonight”, “don’t let negative people talk you out of it”.
- Avoid: You’re told to message friends and family from a script, or to “warm up” people before revealing the offer.
- Avoid: The company name comes up late. First it’s just “a new project”, “a side hustle” or “an AI business”.
- Avoid: The products are more expensive than similar products in normal shops — so hardly anyone outside the team buys them.
- Avoid: Leaving is hard: stock can’t be returned, or people who quit are treated as “losers” or “quitters”.
05 How they use AI now
On this site, we are big fans of AI as a tool for honest work. But the same tools also make recruiting cheaper, faster and more convincing. Here is what we see more and more:
How to spot AI-made “success”
- Look for odd details in photos: hands, text on signs, reflections, repeated objects in the background.
- Do a reverse image search (Google Lens or TinEye). Stock photos and AI images often show up elsewhere.
- Check the account: new profile, few real friends, only success posts, comments that all sound alike.
- Ask for proof that can’t be faked in two minutes: tax returns or an official, complete income disclosure statement — not a screenshot.
- If a message feels very personal but you have never talked before, assume it was written by a tool for many people.
06 The typical story
We won’t show you fake testimonials — that would be exactly what we warn against. But after many conversations and reports, the same pattern comes up again and again. Here it is, as a composite. No real names, no real company.
Someone from school messages after years of silence. Compliments, questions about your life, then: “I’m working on something from home. Can I show you? No pressure.”
A video call with an “upline” leader. Lots of energy, a nice home in the background, stories about quitting a job. The product is mentioned; the opportunity is talked about much longer.
You buy the bigger starter kit, “because serious people take the serious pack”. You join the group chat. For a few weeks it feels great.
You post daily, message your contacts, sell to your mother, your sister, two colleagues. Then the sales stop. Friends start to avoid your messages.
To keep your rank, you order more each month. You tell yourself it’s an investment. Stock piles up. The bonus from your two recruits doesn’t cover it.
After a year you stop. You count what you spent and what came back. You’re in the red — and you feel ashamed, because the group told you that people who fail “didn’t want it enough”.
07 Already in? How to get out
Getting out is mostly about three things: stop the payments, recover what you can, and protect your relationships and your self-worth. Take it step by step.
Log in and cancel any subscription, “autoship” or monthly order today. Check your bank and card statements for payments you forgot. If you can’t cancel online, cancel in writing (email) and keep a copy.
List everything you paid (kit, orders, events, tools, travel) and everything you received. Seeing the true figure is painful, but it ends the “one more month” thinking.
Read the company’s policies and your contract for a buy-back or return rule for unsold products. Many consumer laws also give you a withdrawal right for online purchases within a short period. Ask in writing, name the order numbers, set a deadline.
If you paid by card and something wasn’t delivered as promised, ask your bank about a chargeback. For recent payments, act quickly — there are time limits.
Mute or leave. Honestly, you don’t owe anyone an explanation. Expect pressure (“you’re giving up just before it works”). A short message is enough: “I’ve decided to stop. Thanks.”
A simple “I’m sorry I pushed that on you, I’m out now” repairs a lot. Most people are relieved.
Consumer advice centres can help you with refunds and contracts. In Germany, for example, the Verbraucherzentrale; across the EU, the European Consumer Centres help with cross-border cases. If money problems grow, look for free debt advice in your country.
If you were misled about income, pushed to buy stock, or recruited into what looks like a pyramid, report it (see section 10). Reports help authorities spot patterns — even if yours alone doesn’t lead to a case.
08 What to do instead
The good news: you don’t need a pay plan or an upline to earn online. You need a real product or service, real customers and time to learn. These green-flag opportunities start small, don’t need a big starter kit and let you keep what you earn:
Not sure which fits you? Take our 2-minute quiz — it suggests three opportunities that match your time, budget and skills.
09 How to check any offer
Use this checklist for every “opportunity” — MLM, course, app or “AI system”. If you can’t answer a question with a clear, checkable yes, don’t pay.
- Do: I can earn money only by selling to real customers, without recruiting anyone.
- Do: I’ve seen a complete income disclosure statement — including the people who earned nothing — and I know the typical (median) result.
- Do: I know all costs: joining, monthly minimums, events, tools, shipping.
- Do: There is a written refund or buy-back rule for unsold products.
- Avoid: Someone asks me to decide today or says doubts are “negative thinking”.
- Avoid: The “proof” is screenshots, lifestyle photos or testimonials only.
- Avoid: I would need to buy products myself to reach a rank or bonus.
- Avoid: The person recruiting me earns from my sign-up — and didn’t tell me.
AI can help you read a pay plan, but it can’t see what the company does in practice. Treat its answer as a second opinion, not a verdict. Check the company name with your consumer protection authority and search for “[company] + complaint” or “[company] + income disclosure”.
10 Legal & reporting
MLM vs. pyramid scheme — the difference
An MLM that pays mainly for real sales to people outside the network can be legal. A pyramid scheme pays mainly for bringing in new people. The EU puts it into law in almost these words: it is always unfair to run or promote a scheme where people pay for the chance to earn money that comes “primarily from the introduction of other consumers into the scheme rather than from the sale or consumption of products”. The FTC’s US guidance looks at the same question: are rewards tied to real sales to end users, or to recruiting and to purchases distributors make to qualify for bonuses?
Important: a company does not become legal just because it has a real product. And a legal MLM can still be a bad deal for you. Legality is decided by courts and authorities case by case — so we don’t label specific companies, and you shouldn’t rely on anyone who says “it’s 100% legal, so it’s safe”.
Where to report
- United States: Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov — and your state attorney general.
- United Kingdom: Report Fraud (reportfraud.police.uk), which replaced Action Fraud for England, Wales and Northern Ireland. In Scotland, contact Police Scotland on 101. For consumer problems, Citizens Advice can help.
- Germany: your regional Verbraucherzentrale for advice and complaints. Pyramid-style schemes (“progressive Kundenwerbung”) can also be a criminal offence — you can go to the police.
- Other EU countries: your national consumer protection authority. For cross-border cases, the European Consumer Centre (ECC-Net) in your country.
- Social media: report fake income posts and scam DMs directly on the platform. It takes 30 seconds and helps others.
General information, not legal advice. Laws differ by country and change over time. For your specific situation, ask a consumer advice centre or a lawyer.
11 FAQ
Is MLM illegal?
Not in general. MLM is legal in many countries, including the US, the UK and EU member states. Pyramid schemes — where the money comes mainly from recruiting — are illegal. Some businesses call themselves MLM but work like a pyramid in practice. That’s why you should look at how people are paid, not at the label.
But I know someone who really makes money with it.
That can be true. A small group at the top can earn well. The problem is the rest: the FTC staff review of 70 income disclosure statements found that most participants received $1,000 a year or less, before costs. Your chance of reaching the top is small, and the people at the top earn partly from those below.
The product is good. Isn’t that enough?
A good product is nice, but it doesn’t fix a bad pay plan. Ask: would people outside the network buy it at this price? And could you earn without recruiting? If not, the product is mainly a ticket into the scheme.
Someone pitched me an “AI business” with a team structure. Is that MLM?
Very often, yes — or something close to it. If you pay to join, earn mainly by signing up others, and have to buy upgrades or “licences” to stay active, it follows the same pattern. The AI label changes nothing about where the money comes from.
I spent a lot and feel stupid. What now?
You’re not stupid — these offers are designed by professionals to be convincing. Stop all payments, ask for refunds in writing, get free help from a consumer advice centre and report the offer. Then put your energy into something where customers, not recruits, pay you.
The Offer Check
- 12 questions to ask before you pay anything
- Recruiting vs. real sales: the 60-second test
- How to read an income disclosure statement
- Red-flag phrases in DMs and social posts
- Spotting AI-made “success” posts and screenshots
- Where to report in the EU, UK and US